The People vs The Government

A permanent public record of where the Australian government acted against, or without, the will of the people. Sourced. Documented. Permanent. Because decisions made at 4am behind closed doors deserve to be remembered.

Overall Score — People's Government vs Canberra
The People's Parliament
Govt Ignored the Public
5
documented cases where govt acted with public
VS
The Real Government
Govt Did What We Asked
1
documented cases where govt acted with public
What These Entries Mean
5
Times People Were Ignored
Government acted against or without the public's clear wishes
1
Times Govt Did What We Asked
Government broadly acted in line with what Australians wanted
1
Partial / Ongoing
Government partially responded or issue is still developing
Full Decision-by-Decision Record
People's Government won
Canberra won
Draw / comparable
Issue People's Decision Canberra's Decision Outcome Date
🗳 The Voice to Parliament Referendum
Constitutional · Oct 2023
REAL REFERENDUM RESULT
No — 60.06% of Australians voted against the Voice in a national referendum. Every single state voted No. Only the ACT voted Yes.
✔ The people were asked. The people answered clearly.
Despite the national No vote, South Australia proceeded with its own state Voice, holding elections in March 2024. Victoria's First Peoples' Assembly continued advancing treaty. City of Sydney Council resolved to keep implementing Voice, Treaty and Truth — without another public vote.
⚠ States and councils implementing what the nation rejected — no further public vote held.
People Ignored Oct 2023
AEC Source
📈 Immigration Levels
Immigration · 2022–2024
71% of Australians supported a temporary pause on migration until infrastructure caught up (IPA/Essential/Resolve polling 2023–25). 59–79% said current levels were too high across multiple independent polls.
Clear consistent public majority across multiple pollsters
Net migration hit a record 536,000 in 2022–23 — the highest in Australian history. The government called it "unsustainable" only after the damage was done. Levels only began falling in 2024–25 under pressure.
Record migration — 1 new home built for every 3+ arrivals. Housing crisis accelerated.
People Ignored 2022–24
IPA Poll
💸 Stage 3 Tax Cuts
Economy · Jul 2024
48% wanted them scrapped (Australia Institute, Oct 2022). Only 22% wanted to keep them as originally legislated. The cuts disproportionately benefited earners over $120K — about 4% of Australians.
Public consistently opposed original high-earner design across multiple polls
Both Labor and Liberal promised to keep the cuts at the 2022 election. Labor later modified them in January 2024 — but only after breaking an explicit promise. The $254 billion, decade-long cuts still proceeded despite majority opposition to the original design.
Passed despite opposition. Bipartisan promise made before the election — public had no real choice.
Partial Win Jul 2024
Aus Institute
🏠 Housing & Rent Crisis
Housing · 2022–present
60% of voters supported capping immigration until sufficient affordable housing was built (Essential Poll, May 2023). Broad public support for significant social housing investment and rent caps consistently shown in polling.
Public demanded action on both supply and demand sides of housing
Federal government spent just $9.2B on housing while migration added 536,000 people in one year. The 1.2 million homes target announced but completions running at 173,000/year — well short. Rents rose 47% since 2020. No rent caps introduced federally.
Supply fell catastrophically short of demand. No federal rent intervention.
People Ignored Ongoing
ABS Source
♿ NDIS — Eligibility Tightened
Disability · 2023–24
Polling consistently showed strong public support for maintaining or expanding NDIS access. The scheme was created following overwhelming community demand after the 2011 Productivity Commission inquiry found systemic failure of disability support.
NDIS was itself a people-driven policy — community pressure forced its creation
The Albanese government tightened NDIS eligibility in 2023–24 and introduced a $14.4B savings target. Thousands of participants had plans cut or access removed. The government framed this as "sustainability" — critics called it cost-cutting on the vulnerable.
Eligibility narrowed, plans cut, $14.4B savings target imposed without public mandate.
People Ignored 2023–24
NDIS.gov.au
⚡ Renewable Energy — 82% by 2030
Environment · 2022–present
Strong consistent public support for renewable energy transition. Majority of Australians support accelerating the shift away from coal and gas, particularly after 2019–20 bushfire season.
Broad public mandate for transition — one of the clearest areas of agreement
Government set 82% renewables target by 2030 and passed the Climate Change Act 2022 enshrining a 43% emissions reduction target. Broadly aligned with public sentiment — a rare example of government acting with the community.
✔ Government broadly followed public direction on this issue.
Aligned 2022–25
DCCEEW
🚬 Tobacco Tax — World's Highest
Health/Economy · Ongoing
Public opinion on tobacco tax is divided — many support keeping it as a health deterrent. However, working-class Australians who smoke at higher rates bear a disproportionate burden. A single pack costs $50+. Many call this a regressive tax targeting the poor.
⚡ Mixed — health vs cost-of-living tension. This is why we ask.
Australia has the world's highest tobacco taxes, raised repeatedly without public consultation. The tax raises ~$15B/year. The Albanese government continued raising excise annually. Low-income smokers — the majority — were never asked.
Repeatedly raised without referendum or broad consultation. Disproportionate burden on low-income Australians.
Vote Pending Ongoing
Cast Your Vote
🔒 Freedom of Information — Dismantled Quietly
Government Transparency · 2011–2026
NO PUBLIC VOTE — NO DEBATE — DONE QUIETLY
Australians have never voted on weakening FOI laws. No referendum. No election promise. No mandate.
FOI in plain English:
You can legally write to any federal department and demand to see their documents. Emails, spending records, cabinet notes. It is how journalists expose corruption and how ordinary Australians find out what is being done in their name. Or it was, before the government quietly made it nearly impossible to use.
FOI requests granted in full: 59% in 2011–12 collapsed to 21% in 2023–24. Refusals doubled. Average wait for an appeal: 15.5 months (was 6 months in 2016). In 2025 the government tried to make it worse — banning anonymous requests, adding fees, expanding secrecy exemptions. Condemned by every anti-corruption and media freedom body in Australia. Only withdrawn in March 2026 when the Senate was about to vote it down.
The 2023 Senate inquiry called FOI "dysfunctional and broken." The government tried to restrict it further — without asking Australians.
Never Asked Bill Defeated 2011–2026
TI Australia
Public Integrity

Satisfaction scores are based on post-decision community polls. Updated within 30 days of each real government decision.  ·  View full archive